When our congregation looked into the various online giving/offering options, here’s our research, based on a small church and not expecting a lot of buy-in to start with, since we have a lot of older members without computers and smartphones. I will continue to update this as I find more.

Note that we ended up choosing SecureGive when this was published, but your choice will depend on your needs.

UPDATE 2020: The table below is out of date, and I encourage you, as you consider multiple solutions, to check out Rebelgive, which offers a different model, and I’ve found it to generally be the most affordable for churches — we switched away from SecureGive and have been very happy with it.